Key takeaways
- Great Zimbabwe was built by ancestors of the Shona between the 11th and 15th centuries.
- Colonial-era writers invented foreign origins, and Rhodesian authorities pressured archaeologists.
- Chinese porcelain and glass beads show trade links across the Indian Ocean.
Rising out of the hills of south-eastern Africa are walls of dressed granite, some more than ten metres high, built without mortar. They surround a great enclosure, a hill complex and a valley of homes. For more than a century, outsiders tried to prove that Africans could not have built them. The evidence says they did.
The myth-making
When the German explorer Karl Mauch visited in 1871, he was convinced the ruins must be the lost city of the Queen of Sheba. Later European writers proposed Phoenicians, Arabs, or a vanished white civilisation. The reasoning was racist and political: if the site was foreign, then European settlers could claim a prior and legitimate heritage in the land. Cecil Rhodes’s company, and later the white-minority government of Rhodesia, promoted such theories and discouraged scholars who disagreed.
What the evidence says
Excavation tells a different story. In 1929 the British archaeologist Gertrude Caton-Thompson, after a careful study, concluded that the ruins were of African origin, and later radiocarbon dating confirmed that the city flourished from roughly the eleventh to the fifteenth century. Pottery, building style and oral tradition connect it to ancestors of the Shona. At its height it may have held ten thousand people or more.
A hub of trade
Great Zimbabwe sat at the centre of long-distance trade. Excavations have found Chinese porcelain, Persian ceramics and glass beads, which probably travelled through the Swahili ports of the Indian Ocean in exchange for gold and ivory. Cattle were central to its wealth. Its decline in the fifteenth century may have come from exhausted resources and shifting trade routes.
Editorial assessment
The site is a lesson in how history can be used as a weapon. Denying that Africans built Great Zimbabwe was not an innocent mistake, but a claim that supported colonial rule. When the country gained independence in 1980, it took the name Zimbabwe, from the Shona for “houses of stone.” The reclaiming of the monument shows that archaeology can be an act of justice as well as of knowledge.
Questions to think about
- How does denying a people’s history serve those in power?
- What responsibilities do archaeologists have when their findings are politically sensitive?
Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.
References and sources
- Gertrude Caton-Thompson, The Zimbabwe Culture: Ruins and Reactions (1931)
- Innocent Pikirayi, The Zimbabwe Culture: Origins and Decline of Southern Zambezian States (2001)
#colonialism #archaeology #Zimbabwe
Discussion
Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines